Skip to main content

New Wave of Lehman Litigation Appears to Be Imminent

Financial Services Blog

Financial Services Watch Blog
May 23, 2017

woman is signing contract with business man in backgroundThousands of mortgage lenders across the country either recently received, or will soon be receiving, this document from Lehman Brothers Holdings, Inc. (LBHI). It is a notice of a motion to approve a proposed settlement of Residential Mortgage-Backed Securities (RMBS) claims asserted by trustees and investors against LBHI over the last few years. The notice of proposed settlement refers to proposed findings of fact, sets a deadline (June 22) for objections to the settlement, and schedules a hearing date (July 6) for approval of the RMBS settlement.

The companies receiving this document are apparently those that LBHI believes originated and sold loans that are now part of the proposed settlement, which sets an estimated settlement price of $2.416 billion to be paid by LBHI to settle the claims against it. It is therefore a prelude to new payment demands (for alleged breaches of contractual representations and warranties) by LBHI against the mortgage lender/correspondent at some point after the bankruptcy court approves the settlement. This notice likely is also specifically motivated by LBHI’s desire to cut off one of the potential defenses to an indemnity claim, “failure to give notice.” Paragraph 3 of the proposed order appears to relate to that issue.

As regular readers of this blog are aware, I have spent a tremendous amount of time since the 2008 financial crisis defending companies against RMBS-related claims for contractual indemnification or repurchase (a.k.a. “mortgage buyback” or “mortgage put-back” claims). Our litigation and dispute resolution team has always believed that there are numerous strong defenses, legally and factually, to this type of claim. That belief has translated into a number of precedent-setting victories that we have obtained for our clients, as well as favorable settlements before and after lawsuits were filed.

With regard to LBHI in particular, the RMBS settlement, once it is approved by the bankruptcy court (LBHI has been in bankruptcy since September 2008), will likely usher in a “fourth wave” of lawsuits by LBHI against the lenders that sold it residential mortgage loans. First, LBHI typically sued lenders in venues close to the lenders’ headquarters. They then shifted strategies, filing claims in Colorado, close to the headquarters of their affiliate Aurora. After setbacks in each of those first two waves, LBHI began bringing lawsuits against lenders in the Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York. It commenced a third wave of litigation seeking reimbursement for settlement payment commitments it made to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Now, the fourth wave—seeking reimbursement for RMBS settlement payment commitments—appears to be on the horizon. Significant legal and financial challenges lie ahead for all who are sued, or threatened with suit. Again, however, strong defenses are also very much part of the potential equation for anyone sued.

A “service list” exists, identifying all companies that LBHI believes must be notified about the RMBS settlement. Please feel free to reach out to me if you are interested to learn whether your company is on the list.

Philip R. Stein

Philip R. Stein

Partner, Litigation Practice Group Leader
Financial Services Watch Blog March 16, 2021
If you thought Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. (“LBHI”) was done suing lenders as a result of its settlements with RMBS trustees years ago, think again. LBHI recently filed a new wave of lawsuits against approximately 60 defendants, mostly mortgage brokers, in the bankruptcy proceedings currently pend...
Financial Services Watch Blog March 19, 2018
On March 8, the Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York concluded a lengthy “claims estimation” trial to determine the appropriate final settlement price for a resolution of lawsuits filed on behalf of investors in residential mortgage-backed securities (RMBS) created by Lehman Brothe...
Financial Services Watch Blog December 17, 2020
One would think that, as we approach 2021, litigation related to residential mortgage loans originated and sold well over a decade ago would be ancient history. Nevertheless, some suits filed years ago remain active, and, even more surprisingly (and disturbingly), new lawsuits related to loans sold ...