Skip to main content

Can Fannie and Freddie Cope Under Pressure?

Robert M. Siegel

Last week, the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) put Freddie and Fannie to the test, and the results were grim. Dodd-Frank mandated “stress tests,” designed to evaluate a financial institution’s ability to withstand an economic downturn, revealed that in a severe recession Fannie and Freddie could require bailouts of as much as $190 billion, a staggering figure considering the $187.5 billion these agencies received in the wake of the last housing crisis.

As dictated by the terms of their previous bailouts, Fannie and Freddie’s excess profits (which were at record highs last year) above minimum net worth thresholds are remitted to the U.S. Treasury. The GSEs’ resulting lack of capital explains their poor performance under pressure.

Just days before the stress tests, the Senate Banking Committee postponed voting on a bill to wind down Fannie and Freddie over the course of the next five years. Thanks to the lobbying efforts of the GSEs and private investors, as of April 29th that bill lacked the votes in the Senate Banking committee that it needed to make it to the Senate floor for a vote.

However, regardless of whether the GSEs are phased out, the stress test results should be taken into consideration going forward. If Fannie and Freddie are continually required to remain undercapitalized, absent another bailout, they will never be able to withstand another housing crisis.

Related Practices
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE
Blog November 13, 2026
Miami-Dade County has adopted four ordinances implementing procurement reforms designed to streamline processes, reduce administrative burdens, strengthen transparency and accountability, and support small business participation.
Client Alert November 13, 2026
Democrats will control both houses of Congress in 2027, but the One Big Beautiful Bill Act remains the law and the presidential veto likely limits major tax reform before 2029. Learn what the shift means for estate, gift, and international tax planning, and why high-net-worth clients should act unde...
Speaking Engagement November 12, 2026
Ryan J. Coyle discusses how advisors can coordinate tax, estate, investment and planning strategies for complex client families during the panel Collaborative Planning in Action: A Multidisciplinary Approach to Complex Clients at the 21st Annual Financial Planning Association of Miami Symposium in K...
VIEW MORE