Data Breaches May Cost Corporations and Their Directors Dearly

March 20, 2017

Yahoo! has taken several hits in the last six months for failing to protect its users' electronic information. Its September, 2016 announcement of a massive 2014 data breach that exposed the email addresses and other personally identifiable information ("PM") of approximately 500 million accountholders derailed its proposed merger with Verizon and sent Yahoo! stock prices plummeting. Mere months later, in December, 2016, Yahoo! announced a second attack in which hackers exposed or stole information for another 500 million users. The United States Department of Justice has announced the indictment of two Russian hackers believed to be responsible for the security breach.

Earlier this month, Yahoo! announced that an independent internal investigation revealed that Yahoo!'s senior executives, including CEO Marissa Mayer, "failed to properly comprehend or investigate" the 2014 security breach. Yahoo!'s general counsel resigned without severance for his department's inadequate response to the breaches, and Mayer agreed to forego her annual bonus and stock award.

Yahoo! users have filed at least 23 lawsuits in multiple jurisdictions, which have now been consolidated for multidistrict litigation in federal court in San Jose, California.

On January 24, 2017, Yahoo!'s shareholders filed a derivative lawsuit in Delaware Chancery Court against Yahoo!, Mayer and other Yahoo! executives. The complaint in Oklahoma Firefighters Pension Fund and Retirement System et al. v. Eric Brandt et al., is sealed, but is reported to allege that Yahoo! and its executives breached their fiduciary duties to shareholders by failing timely to disclose data security breaches to Yahoo! accountholders. This appears to be the first case of its kind, in which a company's handling, or mishandling, of a data breach, might expose the company and its officers and directors to liability to the company.

Florida companies suffer data breaches or attempted data breaches every day. The stringent reporting requirements in Florida's data breach statute, Chapter 501.171, require companies to take "reasonable measures" to protect and secure electronic data that contains personal information, to report breaches that affect 500 or more individuals in Florida to state regulatory authorities, and to give prompt notice to each individual in the state whose personal information was accessed as a result of a data breach. Companies that discover that 1,000 or more individuals were affected must also notify all consumer reporting agencies. Florida law deems all violations of the statute as unfair and deceptive trade practices, exposing companies to civil liability as well as civil penalties of up to $500,000.00 per breach.

Related Practices
Webinar November 9, 2023
Philip Stein and Matthew Tieman discuss the latest legal issues regarding corporate director and officer liability as part of the Bilzin Sumberg General Counsel Series. They highlight case updates from the courtroom while also covering best corporate practices for minimizing liability.
Speaking Engagement October 20, 2023
Joseph M. Hernandez speaks at Florida CCIM-Miami Chapter on current debt restructuring trends, commercial real estate debt levels, and maturities by industry segment and default risk over the next 3-5 years.
Speaking Engagement October 10, 2023
Sara Herald takes part in various panel discussions at Women@Langan's Women's Leadership Summit. Panelists discuss a range of topics including, the impact of generations of role models, the importance of sponsorship, and the power of "no"/"yes" in difficult conversations.