Skip to main content

Countrywide’s Big-Bank Belligerence: Causation is Defense for Repurchase Demands by MBIA

Philip R. Stein

Big Banks’ Demand on Originators

I’d be hard-pressed to find a lawyer who did not learn in his or her first weeks of law school that “causation” is a fundamental element of contract claims and legal liability. They tell me that if a butterfly flaps its wings in one part of the world, it can cause a hurricane in another part of the world. So, yes, we learn from the poetic back-and-forth of our great justices that “proximate cause” must always play a role – that there must be some clear connection between the alleged wrong and the harm suffered. Makes sense. But, of course, what makes sense only works for Wall Street when it works in their favor.

In the mortgage repurchase world, we see countless instances where the big bank demands an originator “repurchase” a bad loan, yet the alleged breach cited by the bank has nothing to do with the cause of default. For example, a bank will claim that undisclosed debts require repurchase of a certain mortgage loan, but we find that the borrower made payments for years before losing their job. We forcefully point out this disconnect by the banks. They tend to ignore this fundamental issue, or, worse, take the highly dubious position that causation should not be a defense against a “repurchase” demand.

Apparently unfazed by its self-contradiction, however, Countrywide Financial (now owned by Bank of America) invoked this exact defense against MBIA in that company’s ongoing repurchase lawsuit against Countrywide. In other words, Countrywide claimed that MBIA must show proximate cause – that MBIA’s losses were caused by something Countrywide did, rather than just being the result of risks inherent to contracts they signed.

Is it too much to hope that Countrywide has now seen the error of its ways, and will thus cease claiming to originators that causation need not be proved?

Sadly, the answer is almost certainly yes, it is too much to hope for consistency from Countrywide.


Development Conference March 15, 2023
Suzanne M. Amaducci and keynote speaker Jeff Krasnoff, Chief Executive Officer of Rialto Capital Management, discuss the state of real estate debt markets amid ongoing economic uncertainty at Bilzin Sumberg’s 4th Annual Development Conference.
Blog November 2, 2022
As claims based on pre-2008 loans sold and securitized in residential mortgage-backed securities (RMBS) trusts are still being resolved, industry analysts are bracing for a new wave of indemnification claims and put-back attempts. Credit Suisse Securities and Bank of America have both agreed to make...
Blog February 18, 2022
Last week, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York dealt a major blow to mortgage investors in two parallel actions pending for the past few years. The impact proved to be fatal to one of the actions, which was dismissed in its entirety. The other one was barely left standing. ...